Paradoxical answer to “Where does oil come from?” Crossword Clue

 The paradoxical answer to the crossword clue "Where does oil come from?" is WELL, YOU GOT ME. This is because oil is often drawn from a well, but the word "well" can also mean "I understand" or "I get it". So, the answer is both a literal and figurative answer to the question.

This clue appeared in the New York Times crossword puzzle on September 13, 2023. The theme of the puzzle was "Paradoxical answers", so all of the answers were phrased in a way that seemed to contradict themselves. However, upon closer inspection, the answers were all actually correct.

I hope this helps! Let me know if you have any other questions.