Goal that sends a game into overtime Crossword Clue

 The answer to the crossword clue "Goal that sends a game into overtime" is EVENER.

This is a pun on the word "even," which can mean both "equal" and "to make equal." In the context of a sporting event, an "evener" is a goal that ties the score and sends the game into overtime.

Here is an example of how the word "evener" can be used in a sentence:

"The evener goal came with just seconds left in regulation time."

I hope this helps!